My Photo

« Jonathan Reynolds's New England Spider Cake | Main | Russ Parsons's Peach Gelato »

Comments

Fava beans...overrated?

...Yes...that is the sound of me gasping...

WOW! I'm in love! it's goregous, sounds jaw droppingly delicious, and yep, i'm with you, i think favas are a wee bit overrated as well.

i had this very thought Monday night while trying to recreate momofuku's ramen after a looong day of work.
i decided to toss in some edamame and while i was happily chomping on them i thought to myself, why mess with favas when you have edamame and frozen lima beans?

call me overworked, but i'm with you Luisa!

I do love favas, myself-but I can certainly see that one is not always in the mood to peel the little buggers. I am cool with frozen limas myself.Do you like the canned better?

David - yes, it's true! At least for me. They're expensive and a pain in the neck to clean and the payoff isn't really worth it, I find. A chacun son gout!

Ann - glad this dish looks so good to you. And I'm impressed that you tried to recreate Momofuku's ramen! Were you winging it or did you have a recipe?

Lindy - I like frozen limas, but I never tried canned ones until the other night. A revelation, in terms of lima beans, in my opinion. They're smaller and more tender and flavorful. Also, a bit too salty, but nothing a bit of water can't correct.

Don´t give up on the tomato grating! It´s a really great idea, and saves so much time on the blanching/peeling thing. They have to be very ripe, though. I use canned if they´re not. Everyone in this country does, don´t be fooled by the romantic ways of food writers.

oh, i was winging hardcore!
i kind of gave up on recreating the whole thing about halfway through shopping for it, so in the end the only things that had any relation to momofuku were the poached egg and the wakame!
it wasn't nearly as perfect, but it was delicious in it's own way.
man, i wish i could eat that ramen EVERY day!

I don't know about fava beans being overrated but they are WAY expensive (at least here) and they are a LOT of work. And the baby limas instead of peas sound like an improvement to me.

This rice looks very satisfying and the colors are gorgeous.

Firstly,a very innovative recipe, but with overpowering flavors.

This is a very unusual fusion of white wine, lemon juice and saffron as they tend to interfere with the natural flavor of fava beans and asparagus.

Chicken stock and white wine again is not a very usual pairing. However, the usage of any one or the substitution of chicken stock with a seafood stock would have made a lot of difference.

Ximena - glad to hear canned tomatoes could be substituted. I have seen other Spanish recipes with this grating technique, good to know I was following the authentic method! Even if it was maddening... ;)

Ann - I'm impressed. Without a recipe, I'd just sigh and walk over to 1st avenue. Yum!

Julie - it was totally satisfying, a perfect one-plate meal. I used the baby limas instead of the favas, and the frozen baby peas instead of English ones (yet another secret: I actually prefer frozen peas to fresh ones! Yet another collective gasp....)

Esther - I'm not sure I agree with you that this is an unusual combination of flavors. At least in southern European cooking, the combination of saffron with rice and vegetables is quite classic, not to mention using white wine and then stock to simmer it all together. Seafood stock would be a lovely idea if the rice had shellfish in it -t then you'd really be making a paella. I suppose you could also use vegetable stock in this dish, though I am not a fan of vegetable stock - it's often quite dusty-tasting.

I got a chuckle out of your tomato-grating description. I'll be sure to wear an apron when making this dish. I'm also glad to hear that you made this dish with far less olive oil (1/2 cup? scary) than called for. I can't wait to try it- it seems like a combination of all things fresh and comforting.

I read that LA Times article awhile back. Everything about their trip sounded so wonderful, I printed it out and saved it. Spain is my number one culinary destination. I haven't been yet, but my husband and I want to buy a house there eventually. Beautiful rice!

If you made this again would you still grate the tomatoes? That really sounded like a pain! But the dish sounds divine and like a keeper; I can't wait until my kitchen is finished so I can start cooking again.

I'm also in love with canned lima beans. Not sure why but they're tastier than other varieties of canned white bean. My current favourite use for them is in a risotto flavoured with lemon zest.

I stumbled across your blog while I was doing some online research. The recipe looks great, but I can't imagine trying to grate tomatoes. What a mess!

Anne - so much oil, right? I couldn't really figure out why - the dish definitely turns out wonderfully with just a few spoonfuls.

Julie - Spain's a lovely country. I remember by the end of my first trip there (we went to Madrid, then Sevilla, Cordoba and Granada) that I could barely stand to look at another piece of jamon or manchego. And all I wanted was a salad! So bulk up on your greeny leafy vegetables before going ;)

Rebecca - honestly, I probably would grate the tomatoes again, just because as much as I complained about it, I did feel like a virtuous Spanish cook while doing so and that was kind of neat. Of course, I'd only do it again if the tomatoes were any good. In winter, canned all the way.

May - glad to hear I'm not alone! I love the idea of those beans in a lemon risotto - delicious.

Panasianbiz - it was a little messy, though over a rimmed cutting board not that bad. And the flavor was worth it, I think.

I stumbled across this on our stats page and was very entertained and a little amazed at how far our little recipe had traveled. I agree that the lima beans would be wonderful but they do not exist here in Girona.
Katy agrees that the peppers are unecessary but many people want the little crowning touch-
Martha at Las Nenas

ha ha ha! new reader that I am, was browsing through old posts and was dead chuffed to find this Catalan-oriented one! :)
have tried to get a reservation at "el bulli" a couple of times but it never works, will check "les nenes" out next time I'm up there in Girona (it's been a while, sighs this expat!)

"adoro les faves (a la catalana)!"

The comments to this entry are closed.

Copyright Luisa Weiss 2005-2009


  • All original text and photos © 2005-2009