Samuel Sewall Inn's Maple Scones

Readers of this blog know that when scones show up on the screen here, it's because I've made another batch for Ben. He's an avid breakfast pastry fan - and because I'm totally retro, I try to keep his freezer stocked, because don't we all know that the way to a man's heart is through his stomach? The Settlement Cookbook taught me well. When I had the maple-pecan muffin bake-off a few weeks ago, I planned on giving Ben the muffins (well, after having taste-tested one - or two - myself). But little nibbly bunnies (aka roommates) got in the way and ate up most of the entire bag before I could so.

So when I saw a recipe for maple scones in the New  York Times (and decided to substitute pecans for the walnuts called for), I figured I had no choice but to make them. Besides, the recipe provenance had a special significance. Though I met Ben in New York only a few years ago, we actually went to school together for a short time in a suburb of Boston, and the Samuel Sewall Inn, whose recipe accompanied an article on the maple syrup harvest, is in that same town. Ben and I were on opposite ends of the social strata in 7th grade: he was the popular, trouble-making newcomer, I was the painfully shy loner. It's no wonder we never even met. It's been an amazing experience in human growth to get to know and love him years later. Though it took me a while to realize just how special Ben is, I'm making up for my slow learning curve by baking my way further into his heart.

These scones have an incredible aroma - now totally familiar to my kitchen - of toasty pecans and warm maple flavor. The whole wheat flour adds a substiantial bite (and to make them even healthier, you could substitute cooked wheat berries for the nuts). The scones really are best eaten warm - if you can't serve them right away, heat them up in the oven before you do. And I promise that for the next few months, I'll stay away from the maple-pecan combination (after all, it's spring! Time for berries and joy!). But while rain and gray skies still threaten our city, we're curling up together to munch our breakfast with milky tea and I'm reveling in my good fortune to have landed such a scone-loving sweetheart.

Maple Scones
Yields 8 scones

1 cup whole wheat flour
1 cup white flour
2 tablespoons packed brown sugar
2 teaspoons baking powder
1/4 teaspoon salt
1 stick of butter
1/2 cup chopped toasted walnuts or pecans
1/3 cup maple syrup
1 large egg
2 tablespoons milk or as needed

1. Heat oven to 400 degrees. In a large bowl, combine both flours, brown sugar, baking powder and salt. Using a pastry blender, or two knives scissor-fashion, cut butter into flour mixture until it resembles fine crumbs.

2. Add nuts. Stir in the maple syrup and egg and just enough milk so that dough leaves side of bowl and forms a ball. Turn dough onto Silpat-lined baking sheet and pat (with floured hands) into an 8-inch disk; cut into wedges, but do not separate.

3. Bake until golden brown, about 25 minutes. Immediately remove from baking sheet and carefully separate. Serve warm.

Comments

[Alanna]

Do you actually have a Settlement Cookbook? Me too! Mine's a 1934 version, thanks for the reminder! Must look through it ...

[Leah]

The Settlement Cookbook! I love that you know about and mentioned it. My mother was in possession of a hardcover copy of the 30th edition, printed in 1951. I say was because I, um, borrowed it from her. So amazing!

By the way, I came to your blog on Molly's suggestion, and I've become a regular reader. Lovely stuff.

[Tania]

Another wonderful must-try maple pecan recipe ... I'll bet these smelled incredible while they were baking. I'm with Ben, as I've yet to meet a breakfast pastry I don't love. Cute story about you two, by the way.

[Molly]

Oh man, I'm a sucker for a good love story these days. And yours, my friend, most certainly fits that description, from seventh grade to scones. So sweet!
xo

[Rebecca]

My Pennsylvania Dutch great-grandmother used to say, "Kissing don't last, cooking do."

I'll have to try these now that I cracked open that big can of dark maple syrup to make the granola last week.

[pam]

awww. very sweet! wonder how this'd work with almonds? not sure what cooked wheat berries are, maybe i'll look for those?

[Julie]

Ben sounds like a sweetheart and I think he's a lucky man to have someone who makes it her mission to bake her way into his heart.

[Cathy]

Hi Luisa - those do sound wonderful. Using the cooked wheat berries is a great idea, but don't think I could pass up the toasted pecans! You mentioned earlier in your post about freezing - do these freeze well?

[Ivonne]

I love everything about scones. I especially love a love story that features scones.

What a sweet post!

[Jessika]

You have to quit with the maple syrup recipes ;). I'm turning into a syrup junkie over here ;)!! I'll try them later on.

[From Our Kitchen]

These sound so good. I can almost smell them baking right now.

I always love maple recipes, no matter what time of year. Maybe something with maple and berries would be good for spring.

[Ilana]

this looks gorgeous. will make it very very soon. :)

[Luisa]

Alanna - my mother has an old Settlment; it was the first cookbook I ever read and cooked from.

Leah - I'm so glad you're enjoying the blog. Not sure what edition my mother has, but it's...well, OLD.

Tania - they smelled soo good.

Molly - Makes me giggle every time.

Rebecca - I LOVE this expression, it made me laugh out loud. I'll be using it!

Pam - I'm sure it'd taste good with almonds, though pecans do have that extra-special flavor I love so. But I know your husband's allergic, right? Darn.

Julie - I agree! :)

Cathy - I actually don't know if these ones freeze well, but most scones do - esp because heating them up in the oven recreates that fresh-baked fragrance that's so irrestistible...

Ivonne - thanks!

Jessika - I know...and I'm plowing through maple syrup at an ungodly rate.

From Our Kitchen - that IS a very good idea.

Ilana - hope you like them!

[Darin]

ha.. ha..
it is funny, but I agre with you Luisa, that the way to a man's heart is through his stomach!

[steph]

Yummm, I just made these scones! I love that they are not as dry as terrible store bought scones, and the whole wheat flour is a very nice addition. Thanks!

[Holly]

I just tried these - put them together at 11p on a Friday night for breakfast tomorrow morning. And of course already sampled them. Wow!